For Chinese Adult Learners B1-B2
This I always tell my adult Chinese students "Say TH". And they still say "sink" for "think" and "zis" for "this". It's not their fault. Mandarin, Cantonese, Hakka — none of them have this sound. Their tongues have never had to do this movement before. It's a new gym exercise for their mouth.
1. WHY IT'S SO HARD FOR CHINESE ADULTS
In Chinese, their tongues always stay INSIDE their mouths. For TH, they must break a huge rule: Put their tongues OUTSIDE their teeth.
/s/ and /z/ : Tongue is behind teeth. Air goes over.
/θ/ and /ð/ : Tongue is BETWEEN teeth. Air goes over tongue tip.
Their brain think: "If I put my tongue out, I look silly." So it automatically pulls it back and gives you /s/ or /d/ instead. Adult problem: Children don't feel embarrassed. Adults do. So Chinese adults need a logical reason + a physical feeling to accept the movement.
2. THE TWO TH SOUNDS - They Are Different
Many teachers teach them as one. They are not.
Sound - /θ/ voiceless
Type - Air only, no voice
Feeling - Like a quiet angry cat: "tssss"
Example - think, three, thank you, health, birthday
Sound - /ð/ voiced
Type - Air + voice vibrates
Feeling - Like a bee: "zzzz" with tongue out
Example - this, that, the, them, brother
Chinese adult trick:
/θ/ = s but with tongue out
/ð/ = z but with tongue out
If you can say /s/ and /z/, you can say TH.
3. HOW TO PRODUCE IT - The 3-Step Method for Adults
Do this in front of a mirror. Chinese learners MUST see their tongue.
Step 1: The Tongue Out (1 minute)
Gently bite your tongue tip with your top teeth. Just 3-4mm sticks out. Don't be shy. You should look a bit silly. If you don't look silly, your tongue is not out enough.
Step 2: The Air Test (for /θ/)
Keep tongue there. Blow air out. You should feel cold air on your bottom lip.
Say: th-th-th... No voice.
Now words: think, thank, three, thirty, Thursday, birthday, healthy
Step 3: The Voice Test (for /ð/)
Same tongue position. Now turn ON your voice box. Put your hand on your throat — it should vibrate.
Say: thhhis, thhhis...
Now words: this, that, these, those, the, they, brother, mother, father
Adult checkpoint: If you say "sink", your tongue was INSIDE. If you say "think" with a lisp, your tongue was OUT. A lisp is GOOD. It means you are doing it right. You can make the lisp smaller later.
4. COMMON CHINESE ADULT ERRORS
Chinese learners often replace /θ/ with /s/ because Mandarin lacks interdental fricatives (Swan & Smith, 2001). According to Deterding (2006), final consonant deletion is one of the most common problems for Chinese speakers.
5. PRACTICE
A. Minimal Pairs Drill (Most important for adults - logic)
Read in pairs. The difference is money vs meaning.
think vs sink — I think this plan will sink.
three vs tree — I have three trees in my garden.
thank vs sank — I thank you, the boat sank.
they vs day — _They will come on that day._
those vs dose — Take those, the dose is two pills.
B. High-Frequency Work Sentences Practice these 5 sentences for 1 week.
/θ/ voiceless: Thanks, I think we have three things to think about before Thursday.
/θ/ voiceless: I think my birthday is on Thursday this month.
/ð/ voiced: This is the project that they said is the most important.
/ð/ voiced: My brother and I think this and that should be done together.
Mixed: I think that those three clients will thank us.
C. The Mirror Homework (2 mins / day for adults)
Every morning, brush teeth, then in mirror:
Stick tongue out, say th-th-th-th 10 times (voiceless)
Stick tongue out, say th-th-th-th 10 times (voiced, throat vibrates)
Say: "This, that, these, those" 5x fast.
No need to practice for 1 hour. 2 minutes daily builds muscle memory. Adults fail because they practice 1 hour once a month, not 2 mins daily.
6. TEACHER TIP: How to Correct Adults Without Embarrassing Them
Don't say in front of class: "Wrong! Say TH!"
Adults hate losing face.
Do this:
Silent signal: Agree on a signal — you touch your chin. Means "tongue out please". No words needed.
Fix at the end: Let them finish their 90-second IELTS talk. Then say: "Great fluency. One small fix to sound more native: 2 words — think and this — try tongue out. Show me."
Every Chinese adult, including my best student who now works at Google, had this problem for 6 months. It's normal because Chinese doesn't have it.
References
Avery, P., & Ehrlich, S. (1992). Teaching American English pronunciation. Oxford University Press. Deterding, D. (2006). The pronunciation of English by Chinese learners. Journal of the International Phonetic Association, 36(2), 243–248.
Gilakjani, A. P. (2012). A study of factors affecting EFL learners' English pronunciation learning and the strategies for instruction. International Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 2(3), 119–128.
Swan, M., & Smith, B. (Eds.). (2001). Learner English: A teacher's guide to interference and other problems (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press.
Zhang, F., & Yin, P. (2009). A study of pronunciation problems of English learners in China. Asian Social Science, 5(6), 141–146.



No comments:
Post a Comment